Zillow vs. Redfin | Comparing 2 Real Estate Giants

Zillow vs. Redfin: Comparing 2 Real Estate Giants

When it comes to online real estate platforms, Zillow and Redfin are two of the most recognizable names. Both companies help people search for homes, connect with real estate agents, and access market data. However, they differ significantly in their business models, user experiences, and the services they offer. Understanding these differences can help you decide which platform better fits your needs.

Business Models and Revenue Streams

Zillow and Redfin operate under fundamentally different business models.

• • Zillow primarily acts as a media company. Its main source of revenue comes from selling advertising to real estate agents, mortgage lenders, and other housing-related businesses. Zillow has experimented with direct home buying (iBuying) through Zillow Offers but ultimately exited that market in 2021 due to financial losses.
  • In contrast, Redfin operates more like a traditional real estate brokerage. Redfin employs salaried real estate agents and makes money by earning a commission from each transaction. Unlike Zillow, Redfin’s primary focus is on assisting buyers and sellers through the entire real estate process, not just advertising listings. Additionally, Redfin offers discounted listing fees compared to traditional brokerages, positioning itself as a more affordable option for sellers.

Kentucky Tom Pro Tip:  Mortgage giant Rocket plans on purchasing Redfin

User Experience and Tools

Both platforms offer robust online search tools, but the user experience differs.

Zillow’s strength lies in its broad database and user-friendly interface. It pulls listings from multiple sources and allows users to browse homes, rental properties, and even “Make Me Move” listings, where owners indicate a price at which they might be willing to sell. Zillow’s map search feature, 3D home tours, and Zestimate — its proprietary home value estimation tool — are extremely popular among casual browsers.

Redfin, on the other hand, is known for providing slightly more accurate and up-to-date listings because it pulls directly from Multiple Listing Services (MLS) more frequently than Zillow. Redfin’s website often indicates if a property is already under contract, whereas Zillow may show it as still active. Redfin also provides detailed data analytics, including market competition scores, walkability ratings, and nearby school quality, making it a favorite among serious buyers and data-driven users.

Home Valuation Tools

Both companies offer home value estimators — Zillow’s Zestimate and Redfin’s Estimate. Zillow’s Zestimate is well-known but often criticized for its inaccuracy, particularly in markets with fewer comparable sales. Redfin’s Estimate is generally seen as slightly more accurate because of its direct ties to MLS data and its narrower confidence ranges.

However, it’s important to note that both valuation tools should be considered rough estimates rather than definitive market values. Both Zillow and Redfin recommend professional appraisals or evaluations by local real estate agents when making buying or selling decisions.

Agent Interaction and Service

Zillow connects users to partner agents through advertising, meaning the agents pay to be featured and may not be employees of Zillow. This can result in a wide range of experiences depending on the individual agent’s skill level and customer service approach.

Redfin, by contrast, employs its own agents who follow standardized procedures. Redfin agents are often salaried and receive bonuses based on customer satisfaction, not just sales volume. This model incentivizes a more service-oriented approach and aims to ensure a more consistent experience across the board.

Costs and Discounts

One of Redfin’s strongest selling points is its discounted commission model. Sellers can list their home with a Redfin agent for a fee as low as 1% (compared to the traditional 2.5%-3%), depending on the situation. Buyers may also receive a rebate after closing when purchasing with a Redfin agent in certain states. Zillow does not offer discounts because it does not directly employ agents or handle transactions.

For Your Consideration

Both Zillow and Redfin offer valuable resources for home buyers, sellers, and renters. Zillow excels in providing a broad, user-friendly search platform and extensive advertising opportunities, making it ideal for those in the early stages of browsing. Redfin, with its focus on accurate data, lower fees, and salaried agents, is better suited for users who are ready to transact. Ultimately, the best platform depends on a user’s specific needs, whether that be casual browsing, detailed data analysis, or full-service agent representation.

For More Home Buying and Selling insights, join my Free newsletter by clicking HERE.