Essential Protection for New Home Buyers
Home Warranties
As a home buyer, you’re making one of the biggest investments of your life. Amid the excitement of closing, warranties often get overlooked, yet they can save (or cost) you thousands in repairs. There are two main types: third-party home warranties (optional service contracts) and builder construction warranties (standard on new homes). Understanding their value, limitations, and risks, especially for critical issues like concrete basement wall failures, is crucial.
Third-party home warranties, offered by companies like American Home Shield or Choice Home Warranty, cover appliances, HVAC, plumbing, and electrical systems for an annual fee of $400-$800 plus service calls. They’re marketed to both new and existing home buyers for protection against unexpected breakdowns.
However, experts often question their value. Consumer Reports and NerdWallet note frequent claim denials due to exclusions for pre-existing conditions, improper maintenance, or normal wear.
Payout caps are low, and you might spend more on premiums over time than you receive in benefits. For new homes, these warranties overlap heavily with builder coverage, making them redundant in the early years.
Bankruptcy risk adds concern. While major providers are stable as of 2026, smaller companies have folded in recent years, voiding policies and leaving homeowners without recourse. Corporate insolvencies rose in 2025, though no top home warranty firms were hit hard.
Kentucky Tom Pro Tip:If it’s financially feasible, self-insuring by building an emergency fund (bank account).
Builder Construction Warranties: Stronger Protection for New Builds
New homes come with builder-provided warranties, often backed by third-party insurers like 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty (2-10 HBW). These are far more valuable, especially for structural issues.
Typical coverage includes:
-
- Year 1: Workmanship and materials (everything from drywall to appliances).
- Years 2–10: Major systems (plumbing, electrical, HVAC).
- Up to 10 years: Structural defects in load-bearing components.
Insurance backing ensures coverage persists even if the builder goes bankrupt, which is a real risk during economic downturns.
Surveys show 94% of buyers prefer builders offering robust structural warranties.
Do These Warranties Cover Major Issues Including Concrete Basement Wall Failures?
Basement wall issues are a top concern in regions with expansive soils or poor drainage. Minor hairline cracks from concrete shrinkage are normal and usually not covered beyond cosmetic fixes in year one.
Major failures, including significant cracking, bowing, shifting, or leaks compromising structural integrity, are often covered under the 10-year structural portion.
Providers like 2-10 HBW explicitly protect load-bearing foundation elements, including basement walls, against defects causing the home to become unsafe or unlivable.
Exclusions apply: Damage from homeowner neglect (example: clogged gutters), natural disasters, or external modifications isn’t covered. Claims may require engineering reports, and disputes occur (some buyers report pushback on cracks).
Smart Tips for Home Buyers
-
- Review the warranty booklet at closing (ask for it early).
- Hire a professional inspector to check the foundation, even on new builds.
- Document everything: Photos, measurements of cracks, drainage issues.
- For new construction, confirm insurance-backed structural coverage.
- Skip third-party warranties unless your home is older or you’re risk-averse.
For Your Consideration
While builder construction warranties offer substantial value for new home buyers, particularly for serious structural problems like basement wall failures. Third-party plans provide limited benefits and carry more risk. Prioritize strong builder backing and thorough due diligence.
For More Home Buying and Selling insights, join my Free newsletter by clicking HERE.
You must be logged in to post a comment.