Should a Seller Pay the Buyer Agent Fee?

Should a Seller Pay the Buyer Agent Fee?

In August 2024, the real estate industry underwent significant changes due to a $418 million settlement by the National Association of Realtors (NAR), following antitrust lawsuits alleging inflated agent commissions. These reforms have redefined how real estate agents are compensated, particularly affecting the traditional practice where sellers paid commissions for both their listing agent and the buyer’s agent.

Traditional Commission Structure

Historically, sellers agreed to a total commission—typically around 5% to 6% of the home’s sale price—which was then split between the seller’s agent and the buyer’s agent. This commission was often included in the listing on Multiple Listing Services (MLS), providing transparency and ensuring buyer agents were compensated by the seller. This system allowed buyers to receive agent representation without direct out-of-pocket expenses.

New Commission Rules

Under the new rules effective August 17, 2024, sellers are no longer required to offer compensation to buyer agents, and such offers cannot be advertised on MLS platforms. Buyers must now enter into written agreements with their agents, outlining the agent’s services and compensation. This shift aims to increase transparency and competition among agents but also transfers the responsibility of compensating buyer agents directly to the buyers.

Implications for Buyers and Sellers

Buyers:

- Financial Responsibility: Buyers are now responsible for negotiating and paying their agent’s commission, which can be a significant additional cost, especially for first-time buyers.
- Negotiation Complexity: Buyers must now negotiate agent fees upfront, adding complexity to the home-buying process.
- Potential for Reduced Representation: Some buyers may opt to forgo agent representation to save costs, potentially leading to less informed purchasing decisions.

Recommendations for Buyers

In most cases, it’s smart for buyers to prepare to pay their own agent, but still negotiate seller concessions when possible.

Here’s a practical strategy:

- - - Enter the home search ready to pay your agent — budget for it.
    - When making an offer, ask the seller to contribute a credit toward closing costs, which could cover part or all of your agent’s fee.
    - Be flexible: If it’s a buyer’s market (more houses than buyers), sellers may be willing to pay. But in a seller’s market, they might not.

Sellers:

- Optional Buyer Agent Compensation: Sellers can choose whether to offer compensation to buyer agents. While not required, offering such compensation can make listings more attractive to buyers who might otherwise have to cover these costs themselves.
- Negotiation Flexibility: Sellers have more flexibility in negotiating commissions with their listing agents and can decide on buyer agent compensation outside of MLS listings.

Recommendations for Sellers

Given the new landscape, sellers should carefully consider whether to offer compensation to buyer agents. Here are some factors to weigh:

- - - Market Conditions: In a buyer’s market, offering compensation can make your property more appealing.
    - Buyer Pool: Offering compensation may attract a broader range of buyers, including those who might struggle to pay agent fees out-of-pocket.
    - Negotiation Strategy: Being open to negotiating buyer agent compensation can facilitate smoother transactions and potentially quicker sales.

For Your Consideration

The 2024 changes to real estate commission structures have shifted the financial responsibilities in property transactions. While buyers now bear the direct cost of their agent’s services, sellers have greater flexibility in deciding whether to offer compensation to buyer agents. This new dynamic requires both parties to be more engaged in commission negotiations and to understand the implications for their financial and strategic interests in real estate transactions.

For More Home Buying and Selling insights, join my Free newsletter by clicking HERE.