Should You Take Your House Off the Market If It’s Not Selling?
If your house has been sitting on the market for a while without much interest—or worse, without any serious offers—you’re not alone. Many homeowners find themselves asking: “Should I take it off the market and wait for better conditions?” The answer isn’t one-size-fits-all, but if you’re in the fortunate position of having low carrying costs—no mortgage, minimal property taxes, low utilities and maintenance—then stepping back and waiting could be a smart move. Here’s why, and how to make that decision with clarity and confidence.
The Emotional and Financial Toll of a Lingering Listing
Watching your home sit unsold week after week can feel frustrating and disheartening. You may start second-guessing the listing price, the photos, or even the real estate agent. And if showings are few and far between, it’s tempting to slash the price just to make something—anything—happen.
But slashing the price too quickly, especially in a weak market, could mean leaving tens of thousands of dollars on the table.
That’s why homeowners with the luxury of time and low monthly costs should consider hitting pause. Not permanently, but long enough to regroup and relaunch in a stronger position.
Why Waiting Might Be the Right Move
If your house isn’t generating solid offers and your carrying costs are low, there are several advantages to taking a break from the market:
- You’re Not Hemorrhaging Money
If you own the home outright and your monthly costs are limited to basic utilities, taxes, and minimal upkeep, there’s no urgent financial pressure. That’s a powerful position to be in. It means you’re not forced to sell into a soft market or accept a lowball offer just to cover your bills.
- You Can Wait for the Market to Recover
Real estate is cyclical. Markets rise and fall based on interest rates, buyer demand, job growth, and inventory levels. If local conditions are currently sluggish—homes sitting longer, price reductions common—it might be worth waiting for a rebound. Even a modest shift in interest rates or buyer sentiment can significantly impact your final sale price.
- A Stale Listing Hurts Your Sale Price
Homes that sit on the market too long become what agents call “stale.” Even if there’s nothing wrong with the property, buyers start to wonder why it hasn’t sold.
-
- Was it overpriced?
- Are there hidden defects?
- Is the seller desperate?
When you relist after a break, especially with new photos and a fresh marketing strategy, you get another shot at creating buzz.
When It Doesn’t Make Sense to Wait
Of course, this strategy isn’t ideal for everyone. There are some situations where keeping your house on the market or adjusting your price is the better move:
-
- You need to access the equity soon—for another home, investment, or debt repayment.
- Your local market is declining, and waiting might lead to an even lower sale price later.
- Your home requires ongoing maintenance or attention that’s becoming burdensome.
- You’ve already relocated and managing the property from a distance is impractical.
Kentucky Tom Pro Tip: Opportunity Cost
Are you missing out on reinvesting the money elsewhere—such as a new home, business venture, or investment property? Talk with your financial advisor.
Kentucky Tom Pro Tip: Tax Strategy
Sometimes holding longer may offer capital gains benefits, especially if it’s a rental or inherited property. Talk with your tax advisor.
What to Do During the Downtime
Taking your home off the market doesn’t mean sitting idle. Use this time to make strategic improvements and position your property for future success.
Declutter and Deep Clean
Even if you thought your home was market-ready, a second look often reveals overlooked clutter, personalized décor, or dated fixtures that can be off-putting to buyers.
Address Minor Repairs
Loose door handles, squeaky hinges, cracked tiles—small problems that signal neglect. Fixing them now improves both appearance and buyer confidence.
Upgrade the Listing Strategy
If your original listing didn’t generate results, it may be time to rethink the photos, description, or even your agent. Professional photography, drone shots, and strong copywriting all help set the tone online, where most buyers begin their search.
Study the Market
Use this time to watch what’s happening in your neighborhood and region. Are homes selling faster? Are prices going up or down? Look for trends before reentering the market.
Could Renting Be an Option?
If you’re not in a rush and your home is in a rentable area, consider short-term or long-term rental as a way to offset carrying costs while you wait. With rental income, you keep cash flow moving and remain in control of when you want to list again.
However, keep in mind:
-
- You’ll need landlord insurance.
- You may be subject to local rental regulations.
- A tenant can make it harder to show the home when you decide to relist.
Still, for some homeowners, renting provides a comfortable middle ground between selling now and holding indefinitely.
Watch the Calendar
If you do decide to take your home off the market, aim to relaunch during a high-activity season. Spring is typically the best time to sell, followed by early fall. Listing during a strong season—when buyer demand is higher—can help you generate multiple offers and potentially get your full asking price.
Kentucky Tom Pro Tip: Track metrics like:
-
-
- Median days on market
- Inventory-to-sales ratio
- Interest rates
- Buyer demand in your ZIP code
-
For Your Consideration
If your home isn’t selling and your carrying costs are low, taking it off the market can be a smart, strategic move. You’re not just avoiding the stress of a stagnant listing—you’re buying time to wait for better market conditions, improve the property, and relaunch from a position of strength.
Don’t think of it as giving up. Think of it as pressing pause—so that when you hit play again, you’re ready to win the game.
For More Home Buying and Selling insights, join my Free newsletter by clicking HERE.
You must be logged in to post a comment.